Nicolás Otamendi is strongly associated with a move to River Plate. Despite being a fan of the Buenos Aires club, concerns about the lack of security in Argentina are significant factors in his decision-making process.

Nicolás Otamendi, who serves as a defender and captain at Benfica, conveyed his strong support for River Plate and discussed the possibility of representing the club before concluding his career. He indicated that he feels comfortable at Benfica and acknowledged that returning to Argentina is becoming increasingly challenging. Otamendi's contract with Benfica extends until June 30, 2025, and he underscored his commitment to his current club. He referred to having a good relationship with River Plate's management but expressed a desire to avoid creating false hopes among their supporters. He mentioned that a decision regarding his future would be made after his contract concludes.

River Plate showed interest in Nicolás Otamendi. The Argentine central defender commented on this possibility. However, he ended up renewing his contract with Benfica for two more seasons.

Nicolás Otamendi mentioned that returning to Argentina, specifically to River Plate, is a very complicated scenario due to the lack of security in the country. He received a proposal to play for River Plate recently, which he refused. He also discussed the possibility with the president, who insisted that he could go to River Plate, but Otamendi decided against it for his family's safety and because he had renewed his contract with Benfica.